DNA
Repository and Unsound Move at Howard University.
Written by Evelyne Shuster
to the Washington Post,
May 29, 2003
Re: “Howard University Plans Genetic Database,” May
28, 2003
To the Editor:
The plan by Howard University to create a repository of African-American
DNA is ill advised, ill guided, scientifically unsound and potentially
harmful. Race is not genetic. Craig Venter of Celera Genomics reminded
people the very day he announced the completion of the Human Genome:
“Race is a social construct, not a scientific one. People
must know that there are no genes of any kind that pattern along
racial lines.” If we really want to know why Blacks are more
susceptible to diabetes and hypertension we need to look at social
and living conditions, including racism. And if we really want to
“help Blacks fight diseases” we must help improve these
conditions, fight racism and ensure everyone a decent living standard,
jobs and access to health care. The creation of a repository of
DNA from African Americans is reductionist and could lead to a new
kind of discrimination based on genes rather than skin color. To
think that this would not happen because of the involvement of Howard
University is simply naïve.
— Evelyne Shuster, Ph.D.
— Medical Ethicist,
— Veterans Affairs Medical Center
— Philadelphia, PA

Comments
will be reviewed and
posted on a daily basis.
|